Submitted by twelveparsnips t3_1165hgv in news
jayfrancy t1_j95zvzu wrote
Reply to comment by razorirr in 1 person dies when Tesla hits fire truck on I-680, 4 firefighters injured by twelveparsnips
How many other autonomous systems have had these accidents. That’s the apples to apples.
razorirr t1_j963cf0 wrote
How much do you want to actually read? I can answer this.
NHTSA has a standing order on ADAS crashes. All manufacturers are required to provide telemetry and report if a crash occurred with ADAS either on, or had been on in the previous 30 seconds. This reporting started July of 2021 and is still current.
You can read their june 2022 findings here. next report will be next june
In that whole time period, only 2 crashes were confirmed into first responder vehicles total, for any brand.
So every other article you have seen since june 21 through may15th 2022, the cutoff date in that report, is bullshit. its the press going "oh its a tesla and a responder vehicle, lets accuse AP/FSD, get a shitload of clicks from people on reddit, then not release a retraction months later when its found not to have been the cause"
As to my significantly insignificant bit. yeah, both crashes might have been tesla (the report does not break it down to that detail) But their system works everywhere, and is on way way more cars than Fords or GM. Ford was happy when they hit 16 million miles driven total. Teslas system does north of a billion a year. If tesla was both crashes on 1b miles, ford will have 0, and you can claim that "well ford is perfect" no, ford just has not had enough time to be statistically relevant.
The only other brand to have a significant amount of vehicles is Honda, with about 5 million, Their system however does not function everywhere so theres the question of are they better at not crashing, or do they just not have the crashes per mile figure out there as they have not released miles of usage figures. I can't do apples to apples with them as tesla has shown their apple, and the others all have a black box they say may or may not have a fruit in it.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments