Comments
Ghost273552 t1_j2iu8nk wrote
I thought it was going to be a sarcastic article about helmets.
Background_Dream_920 t1_j2k66kd wrote
Nothing will protect your brain from slamming around in your skull. It’s a futile effort.
Billbat1 t1_j2l2ks6 wrote
it would have to be something inside the skull but if it existed there would have been news about its development for many many years
Background_Dream_920 t1_j2l2ttt wrote
Can’t stop neuronal shearing from sudden deceleration. The only reason they keep trying to up this stuff is so they can keep making billions off people wanting to see these guys kill themselves.
[deleted] t1_j2l5ohx wrote
[removed]
IIIllllIIlllIIlllIIl t1_j2jfvbg wrote
Paywall. I'm a coach in youth sports and also have two boys. What is it and how does it protect the brain?
keptpounding t1_j2jii5t wrote
“The Q-Collar helps protect the brain from the damage caused by repetitive head impacts that can alter brain tissue. Athletes who were not wearing the Q-Collar were three times more likely to have significant changes in their brain tissue”
It restricts blood flow and keeps more blood in your head and somehow that helps prevent concussions.
JK_NC t1_j2ke4fy wrote
My understanding is that it applies light pressure to the jugular pushing more blood to the brain. The idea is that the additional blood increases the size of the brain and reduces the space between the brain and skull. By reducing the space between the brain and skull, you reduce the room that the brain can move and take damage.
This was supposed to be inspired by woodpeckers who can take repeated jarring blows to their head while not suffering the same kind of damage that human brains suffer.
This is the same tech that Luke Kuechly from the Carolina Panthers wore. He started wearing it after a bad concussion. He did suffer from subsequent concussions that eventually ended his career prematurely.
I also saw an article earlier this year, completely unrelated to the Q-collar, that indicated our understanding of woodpeckers and their brain saving mechanisms was incorrect.
Anyway, it sounded like an innovative tech like 6 years ago. I haven’t seen or heard much about it since but I believe Kuechly is still publicly supportive of the tech and has stated that he believes it extended his career.
mankls3 OP t1_j2jhr9l wrote
q collar pushes bloood into head
2779 t1_j2pf0re wrote
maaaaybe helps soften the blow but... the brain floats inside the skull, if smack your head hard enough for your brain to contact the inside of your skull it's technically a concussion and you've technically caused some amount of damage to the soft squishy tissue. adding extra blood or packing peanuts for that matter will prevent damage entirely. fun fact: the flash of light you see when you hit your head is actually bc your occipital lobe in the BACK of your brain got slapped on the ricochet
naois009 t1_j2k9nbr wrote
Didn't Luke Kuechly start wearing this and suffered a bad concussion like the first week?
mankls3 OP t1_j2kaqfb wrote
yes
Shakespurious t1_j2ju8nn wrote
I think we learned long ago that protective gear often results in more brain damage since fewer broken noses or fingers (in boxing) encourages more and harder contacts.
TrillBillyDeluxe t1_j2k38hl wrote
That’s my theory on rugby vs football , they have to have more control because your head is just as exposed as the guy your tackling
s1lentastro1 t1_j2l0nsc wrote
give Tua Tagovailoa three of those, Dark Helmet's helmet with extra padding, and teach him how to tuck his chin ffs.
xpen25x t1_j2lpsc2 wrote
Only thing that will help is to slow the impact. Those funky helmet covers actually do help. Nothing will stop concussions though except not hitting your head
[deleted] t1_j2nuqca wrote
[removed]
fordman84 t1_j2n1x89 wrote
It's a cock ring for your northern most brain.
stxrxer t1_j2imkvs wrote
It won’t.