Ribak145

Ribak145 t1_jee1oxu wrote

you could also ask "when will modern operating systems actually start taking jobs" and ignore the reduction of secretaries, you could ask the same question about productivity tools like Excel and ignore the exploding rise of productivity of workers since 1970 etc. -> its still mostly an efficiency effect

that happens across the board, across departements and across levels, f.e. Mercedes CEO 2018 announcing cutting 10k people, especially in middle management (I still remember how disturbed people were about that announcement all over Germany at that time)

so 'taking jobs', as in completely annihilating specific jobs throughout the world -> takes centuries, dont wait for it, cultural stickiness prevails for a long duration

but expanding usefulnes of services, raising efficiency etc. creates a lot of value, and to my knowledge AI-systems are already doing that (long before GPT)

3

Ribak145 t1_j8f6pr0 wrote

Altman thinks midterm, Yudkowsky longterm

the former deals in business, the latter in theory

while basically nobody thinks that AI wont have a huge impact on the economy (i.e. everyone agreeing with Altman), Yudkowsky has yet to be proven wrong in his statement that ours is the time of failed AI alignemnt. I have yet to discover a practical solution the alignment problem and I more and more believe that he may be right, which would pretty terrible for all of us

9

Ribak145 t1_j57aoy8 wrote

No I think you're on to something, I just think its much simpler than that - alignment of AI systems with humans is already difficult (to my knowledge not yet solved), but the much bigger problem is that even we humans are not aligned, so even if we 'solve' the alignment problem (which imo is unsolvable), we still only align the AI systems to their engineers/owners and ignore 99,9% of the rest

2

Ribak145 t1_j23651f wrote

to my knowledge encryption standards like AES are not yet broken by any computing, only via bruteforece i.e. the math is still holding up

but the crowd within IT-Sec yelling 'quantum computing is killing encryption' is getting louder every day

6

Ribak145 t1_j1pwuck wrote

there is an argument to be made that people dont care so much for perfect information, but rather care about access and presentation

the presentation of info with Google search is horrible compared to Chat-AIs

−1