https://tirereviewsandmore.com/top-10-longest-wearing-all-season-tires/

You can place your faith in two things: Treadwear and warranty. You find the Treadwear literally on the tire or the maker's website. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/93/UTQG_ratings_on_Japanese_Tire.jpg

The Treadwear will be on the tire as its like a federal law and stuff.

Having said that....you are compromising the safety of your car by sorting by highest Treadwear/longest warranty.

And the other idea to consider is you don't need to go full retard just because you had a bad experience with Kmart tires. You can/should find tires suited for your climate and vehicle and I'd recommend you visit tirerack.com and see what's best for your car before buying some shopping cart wheel tires onto your car an increasing your stopping distances by 300%.