Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

ThePlanetMercury t1_ir38fhd wrote

Wow they actually linked the study! https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamasurgery/article-abstract/2786671?utm_campaign=articlePDF&utm_medium=articlePDFlink&utm_source=articlePDF&utm_content=jamasurg.2021.6339

Thanks for sharing this, this paper was an interesting read. That stat is only part of the story. Women were consistently less likely to die if the surgeon was female, and men were also more likely to die if the surgeon was male. Also, across the board, women were consistently less likely to die than men regardless of surgeon sex. That was surprising to me seeing how how medicine has largely ignored women's health for a long time. This seems to point either to a difference in treatment quality between men and women surgeons, or a difference in the risk level of surgeries performed by men and women surgeons. I'd be really interested to look more into the mechanism driving this disparity.

5

carrotv t1_ir3gd32 wrote

You make a lot of good points about risk taken. I wonder what percentage of leading surgeons in complex surgeries are female.

I’d also be interested in seeing more about race - I don’t have an article or study handy, but I’ve read in the past that many medical textbooks and materials are specifically geared toward how issues an diseases present on caucasian skin. Especially in dermatology, there seems to be a gap in providing care to people with much darker skin complexion as a result. I wonder if somehow that may carry over into many other areas as well.

2