Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

thisischemistry t1_itxvs7m wrote

Reply to comment by mirhagk in Move over, diesel: Ohio gets ‘first of its kind’ renewable gas station by redingerforcongress

It's only net-zero if you don't consider all the other inputs, such as the fuel used in processing and transporting feed. A considerable amount of energy goes into farming and there are considerable impacts from the farming.

I agree that if this methane capture and use is a side-effect of farming then it's a bonus to reduce the impact of the farming. It would still be tough to call it net-zero carbon.

2

mirhagk t1_itxx944 wrote

Well yeah the processing and transportation always complicates things, the net-zero is talking about where the carbon that is released is coming from.

Stuff like feed you can't really analyze in the abstract, since there are many different ways it's done, and AFAIK most cattle farms either grow feed on-site or are grass-fed. Transportation costs are expensive, and better farming techniques have expanded the locations grain can be grown. Of course there definitely exists farms that do transport feed in, but looks like this dairy farm in particular is also a grain farm.

I think when looking at investing in things like this it's more important to look at whether it can be net-zero, and whether it's improvement on the status quo. In this case both are true, it could be net-zero with improvements in other areas and it's definitely an improvement on the status quo.

1