Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

DoktoroKiu t1_j35iwvh wrote

>1) How long will it matter that the source of our content is human? At some point I think there will be a gesture towards considering AI a comparable mind and asking them for their experiences and sharing in the joint qualms of existence. I do think that there will be a rubber band snap back of sorts whenever we realize they're smarter than the collective whole of humanity and then our ability to relate will be minimal. Also again, the trust factor of being exploited goes up dramatically.. before I get that out of your mouth

I think that one key issue here is that a true general intelligence (the comparable mind you speak of) is probably a very long way off. ChatGPT and related AIs can simulate talking about qualms of existence, but its true existence is as something which generates plausible responses to text prompts based on its training data. If there's anyone in there with a subjective experience (most likely and hopefully not), it is vastly different from ours.

And if/when we do create an artificial general intelligence there are far more serious things to worry about than whether some person/corporation is exploiting you. Hopefully whoever does it has somehow also managed to figure out all of the AI safety problems to avoid a guaranteed apocalypse. It's a surprisingly difficult problem, and is also very entertaining to think about.

We definitely don't want to find out the hard way what happens when a superintelligent stamp collector AI figures out that it can get the most stamps by overthrowing human governments and diverting all production to stamp printing, or when it finds that humans are a good source of raw materials...

3

gaudiocomplex t1_j35k2cn wrote

Thanks for the reply! And I largely agree. r/controlproblem has been a great sub to follow for some disturbing reads lately, if you're into that sort of thing.

Just wanted to add "Before I get that out of your mouth" was from voice to text for my kid this morning as I read this and she, 4, was trying to eat leaves.

Ironically enough, a robot wouldn't have been able to reproduce that weird blunder so I guess you know I'm human

2

DoktoroKiu t1_j35nrcr wrote

>Thanks for the reply! And I largely agree. r/controlproblem has been a great sub to follow for some disturbing reads lately, if you're into that sort of thing.

Thanks for the sub recommendation, I was not aware of it. I've been getting my fix from computerphile videos on youtube, and all of the great videos by Robert Miles on his channel.

It's fascinating just how much we can know just by reasoning about advanced AI even when we have no idea how to make it or when we will.

>Just wanted to add "Before I get that out of your mouth" was from voice to text for my kid this morning as I read this and she, 4, was trying to eat leaves.

Ha, I did wonder about that, lol.

>Ironically enough, a robot wouldn't have been able to reproduce that weird blunder so I guess you know I'm human

Exactly what a superintelligent AI would say ;)

I won't tell anyone if you keep me around as a pet after you take over.

2