Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

enryu42 OP t1_jdsokwz wrote

Reply to comment by farmingvillein in [D] GPT4 and coding problems by enryu42

Interesting! Here are the scraped and auto-converted statements (formatting is off sometimes, especially in the sample tests, but understandable). Prefixes are: "abc" for beginner, "arc" for regular, "agc" for "grand".

I do believe that the "Beginner" ones can be improved, but it'll be interesting to see what happens on "Grand" (or even "Regular"), as they require coming up with some ideas before writing the code.

7

farmingvillein t1_jdspflq wrote

So, don't know whether this actually makes a difference, but I'd review the overall post-conversion text.

E.g.: https://github.com/enryu43/llm_coding/blob/main/atcoder_eval/statements/statement_abc293_b.txt

You'll see that it represent "K" and "N" wrong here (in sample 1, 15 versus 5, 12 versus 2).

Certainly, as a human, I would find this confusing. Maybe you could get some automated robustness by telling it how you converted the text (as it might automatically adjust its "expectations" on interpreting the numbers). Obviously, the fairer comparison though would just be to fix this.

> as they require coming up with some ideas before writing the code.

The other thing I'd note--

Not sure whether you're using the API directly, but if I play around with these in ChatGPT, I often run into the context window and have to nurse it along to complete text. I'd make sure that however you're running things, you're giving it enough "space" to iterate (particularly if you use any reflection techniques).

6