Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

arg_max t1_ixh2wrq wrote

Reply to comment by Acceptable-Cress-374 in [D] Schmidhuber: LeCun's "5 best ideas 2012-22” are mostly from my lab, and older by RobbinDeBank

thats not how scientific citation works though. just because people in the 90s didn't train on JFT-3B and got close to 90% imagenet ACC doesn't mean its purely theoretical. And if ideas were presented earlier they should be cited.

14

[deleted] t1_ixi2ee8 wrote

Ideas are cheap, implementation is everything.

−8

Acceptable-Cress-374 t1_ixh4mo5 wrote

If they're after citations why not simply say so?

−14

respeckKnuckles t1_ixhedyv wrote

Uh...they do

8

Acceptable-Cress-374 t1_ixipz7u wrote

Well, in that case my bad. I don't do academia, and am not up-to-speed with what's the common way to cite previous work & such. To me, a layman, the blog post read more like whining and shaking a fist at the clouds and not like asking for proper citations. Again, my bad if I misread that.

0