Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

jarkkowork t1_j3qsdri wrote

Don't the new results simply make your paper more impactful?

31

[deleted] OP t1_j3qxzpn wrote

They do indeed. They prove that the method scales up well with lots of training, which I couldn’t demonstrate in the preprint paper.

23

Tricky_Condition_279 t1_j3qzs7x wrote

You could ask very politely to discuss this with your editor and just point out that the new work validates and demonstrates the importance of your idea. You can acknowledge the preprint in your revision making it clear it came after your original submission.

16

[deleted] OP t1_j3r0c1m wrote

I see, and would this be done after the reviewed are released or should I reach out to the editor now?

7

Tricky_Condition_279 t1_j3r0ysy wrote

I edit and would not mind if an author reached out as it’s my job. I would do it as soon as possible. But tread lightly and ask your advisor her opinion.

14

[deleted] OP t1_j3r1bxt wrote

Got it. Thanks a million for the advice!

7