Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Fenzik t1_j3qyvke wrote

Reply to comment by [deleted] in [D] Found very similar paper to my submitted paper on Arxiv by [deleted]

Why did you not initially upload to arXiv? Just curious

25

[deleted] OP t1_j3qz0fp wrote

My supervisor advised me against it. She’s not a big fan of putting papers there before they’re published.

39

bill_klondike t1_j3r9lj5 wrote

I disagree with your supervisor and your post pretty much illustrates why!

107

ASuarezMascareno t1_j3rzdg1 wrote

I work in Astronomy, not in ML, but review first and arxiv later is how most people work in Europe. I typically don't find european arxiv papers that are not accepted for publication already. It's different for US papers. US groups are much more aggressive at pushing their work out, but that also means more people getting wrong information when the paper changes significantly in the review process.

27

throwaway2676 t1_j3sxeda wrote

> I work in Astronomy, not in ML, but review first and arxiv later is how most people work in Europe. I typically don't find european arxiv papers that are not accepted for publication already.

I did work in an Astronomy adjacent field, and European researchers in our area all submitted to arxiv first, just like US groups.

5

Cheap_Meeting t1_j3unjt1 wrote

We can't afford that in Machine Learning by the time your paper has passed the review process it's going to be outdated.

5

[deleted] OP t1_j3rmxb0 wrote

Yup! At least I know for the future now.

10

DevFRus t1_j3rk8qb wrote

I think that your supervisor is using arxiv wrong, and giving you bad advice on how to use arxiv.

14

ktpr t1_j3rxi2v wrote

Whats the right way to use arXiv?

6

Cheap_Meeting t1_j3unrox wrote

It's a preprint server, meant to publish preprints.

3

ktpr t1_j3usyfe wrote

That begs the question, what are good ways to use a preprint server to further your academic career

2

anony_sci_guy t1_j3swstr wrote

I feel like everyone in the new generation has this happen once, learns from it, and has started pre-printing everything...

4