Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

TheArmitage t1_jd5hp7t wrote

Reply to comment by Dr-Luemmler in Can a single atom be determined to be in any particular phase of matter? by Zalack

>what happens if we drop a second atom in the void?

In doing so, you've introduced energy into the system. That atom had to get there somehow, and that takes energy.

>Besides that, temperature itself isnt relative as we have a true zero.

Yes, it is. It's just self-referential. Thermal motion is the motion of atoms in a substance relative to each other. So if all atoms in a substance have zero motion relative to each other, it has a temperature of 0K.

6

Acewasalwaysanoption t1_jd5ll20 wrote

Nobody said that we can't have a reference point, just that we have a single atom of an element, as opposed to a macroworld-sized amount to easily determine its phase.

Like if I'm the last person on the world, I can't tell if I'm handsome or if I'm rich, without other people to compare myself. But I know how fast I am, because I don't need other people for a reference system.

3

TheArmitage t1_jd5mdnn wrote

It is inherent in the definition of temperature that the substance is compared to itself. You cannot have an external reference point for temperature, because then it's not temperature.

3

Acewasalwaysanoption t1_jd5oj3o wrote

Sorry, I may have misread something.

New question: what you exactly mean by "compared to itself"? It can't be literally itself in the same state, as it would be the same, all the time. Can't be a chunk of the material, or any material that has the same temperature in its core and surface would be at 0 difference and...incomperable?

Also, using thermometers isn't using an external point if reference in general? Originally nercury's change in volume to tell a completely different material's temperature. Works because energy transfer.

1

Purplestripes8 t1_jd6moch wrote

By compared to itself it means the motions of the atoms within an object relative to each other. The object itself can have any velocity depending on the observer but no matter which direction it's moving as a whole or how fast, the atoms within still have the same motions relative to each other, which is signified by temperature.

1