Submitted by samskiter t3_zsiyxn in askscience
a_cute_epic_axis t1_j18p97i wrote
> But what real life factor means we can't try and use a gas both sides
You can, and some systems do used a pumped refrigerant economizer, where it just pushes the refrigerant around to move heat around without any phase change or any compression at all.
That said, the amount of energy that you use for a phase change is WAY more than you get with simple heating and cooling.
samskiter OP t1_j18pvem wrote
Would that bit be more of a great engine than a heat pump as you are not working against a heat gradient?
a_cute_epic_axis t1_j18r45c wrote
In real world AC applications, if the outside air is colder (or substantially colder), then you run pumps, not compressors, and push the fluid around to move heat energy from inside to the cold outside. You could do this with water or glycol instead, but refrigerant is way more efficient. You could also just push air between the outside and inside, but then you have humidity issues and potentially pollution/contamination issues, which a refrigerant exchange avoids. If the outside air is warmer than the inside air, you switch to compressors and use the phase change to both overcome to inverse heat gradient (which you could not do at all without some amount of compression), and also because the energy exchanged in phase change is super efficient.
While on paper you might be able to keep everything a gas but achieve some comparably insane pressure to get from say below 50F to WAY above 150F on the inside and outside respectively, it's way easier to use a gas/liquid phase change.
You also have other benefits with gas/liquid... you can have an accumulator or a receiver that holds liquid and effectively reduces the refrigerant charge if there is too much refrigerant for the current operating conditions... and you can flood the refrigerant back into the outdoor condenser to effectively reduce its capacity if you are operating in very cold outdoor conditions but still need DX without freezing your inside coil (or don't have the option for pumped refrigerant economizers).
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments