Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

dbx999 t1_j5kfdp4 wrote

I was told that batteries do work well to correct power quality.

I was told that a car battery helped regulate the delivery of a constant 12V current inside the car by buffering and regulating the electricity produced by the alternator.

1

MiffedMouse t1_j5m18e7 wrote

It is a question of timescales. Capacitors are typically used to “smooth out” power over timescales of nanoseconds to seconds (super capacitors can sometimes go up to minutes or hours). Batteries can smooth out power over timescales of minutes to years.

Batteries are also better at “clamping” to a certain voltage, while capacitor voltage is typically more variable.

3

PerspectivePure2169 t1_j5mb8id wrote

Yes batteries can do this for a DC system like in your car. But that is mainly a voltage regulation function.

Power quality correction is a consideration in large industrial AC power networks. It helps with the problems that arise from running large amounts of electric motors where the power factor gets out of balance between inductive and reactive currents.

Since electricity essentially sees the coils within a motor as an inductor, it affects multi-phase power in a way that's detrimental to its ability to transfer power

So capacitor Bank systems are designed to correct the issue so that the overall AC power quality isn't effected for downstream users.

2

hatsune_aru t1_j5nxahk wrote

The actual regulation in a car is done by the ECU or some circuit inside the alternator that limits the output voltage to a certain amount.

The battery is mostly there so that when there is a load transient, the regulator mentioned above can have a relaxed response time--the battery takes up the slack when there's a sudden load increase or decrease.

If a control system has to react quickly, it's more liable to instability like oscillation and divergence. Better to keep it safe by making it slow to react, especially if you already have a big ass battery that can smooth things out that you need to start the car.

1

PromptCritical725 t1_j5qtyxu wrote

This is a reason people with bigass car stereos add capacitors. Large sudden power draws like amps driving large bass hits can cause equally large drops in system voltage. The capacitor act to "stiffen" the system by providing reserve of current that can be drawn and replenished much more rapidly than a battery can. This keeps the voltage more consistent.

1