Submitted by Adventurous-Swim-523 t3_10mswj5 in askscience
Chemomechanics t1_j69s728 wrote
Reply to comment by ejdj1011 in What cause each materials to have different maximum stress and strain? by Adventurous-Swim-523
> For example, strain in metals is due to the crystal structure "realigning" itself, one atom at a time. Doing so fills atomic-scale voids and fixes other defects in the structure. Eventually, you run out of such defects, and the stress is instead applied to the crystal bonds themselves.
[Edited to assume good faith.] This is so very wrong. I suppose you're just making things up or using an AI-generated answer writing without peer-reviewed technical references; the answer also resembles AI-generated answers that are designed to be confident but not designed to be correct.
Elastic strain arises from bonds stretching and recoverable defect movement. Plastic strain arises from unrecoverable defect movement, which itself creates more defects, not fewer. Voids ultimately form and coalesce; they don't disappear. The stress is always applied to the crystal bonds.
ejdj1011 t1_j69smyq wrote
I was just wrong, you don't have to insult me about it.
It is in fact possible to correct someone without being a jerk.
Chemomechanics t1_j69ycqq wrote
My note addresses the comment only, not any aspect of your character. Of course insults have no place in a technical discussion.
ejdj1011 t1_j69z4dk wrote
> I suppose you're just making things up or using an AI-generated answer.
That's an insult if I've ever heard one. The "making things up" is a direct attack of character, as it implies knowingly spreading falsehoods. Just because you say you didn't insult me doesn't make it true.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments