Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

puddingwinchester t1_it6nmlv wrote

I have to disagree. Maybe you should read the other books too.

For example the telepathy thing you thought was good to eliminate is quite important in the other books. Plotlines doesnt work without it so the other movies (especially the second) are totally different.

I agree that the first movie isnt bad, just different from the book. The second movie is really bad in my opinion. The third is better and more like the book but they mixed up many things and put them wrong together.

The books are quite stable in quality to me

4

Trollyofficial t1_it78866 wrote

I agree with you. I enjoyed the books far more than the films.

3

amnesialh t1_it80qsx wrote

Yup. I respect everyone's opinion and it is okay if they don't like the books. I do know it has some flaws, but to me the books are better than the movies.

1

throwaway-clonewars OP t1_it8k3u9 wrote

Oh I am, I was just sharing my first book thoughts before I go on to the rest of the series.

1