Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

BeardMilk t1_j65wxsc wrote

Reply to comment by baghada28 in What’s the longest wait you’ve seen for chekhov's gun to be used? by I_Am_Slightly_Evil

He’s north of the wall in the first episode of season 1. He comes back again in the final season.

13

A_Gringo666 t1_j67mhjl wrote

In ASOIAF he comes back a lot earlier. He helped Samwell Tarly and his wildling girlfriend get to the Wall when they were North.

2

rowan_sjet t1_j67opw6 wrote

We don't know that Coldhands is Benjen

12

A_Gringo666 t1_j68bg7p wrote

Yes sorry your right. I forgot that. It's been a while since I read them and the show had a habit of blending multiple characters into one e.g Sansa/Jeyne. It's quite possible that Coldhands isn't Benjen.

My mistake.

2

rowan_sjet t1_j69j4jq wrote

No worries, I may have sounded more curt than I intended! There's a strong chance they are one and the same, but just wanted to clarify that it's not a certainty.

2

A_Gringo666 t1_j6ay95k wrote

There is a good chance they are, but we don't know that yet bookwise.

I didn't find your comment curt at all, by the way.

1