Icy-Neck-2422 t1_jdxk82o wrote on March 27, 2023 at 10:40 PM

Different plumbers will have different takes on what the "right" way to do a job is. Unless there are code/health/sanitary concerns in play then if one of them says that the stack is in good shape and only the drains/traps and supply lines /shutoffs need attention/replacement then I'd probably go with them if they seem like they know what they are doing.

lifeisakoan t1_jdy5028 wrote on March 28, 2023 at 1:13 AM

You play roulette with inspectors. And depending on plumber, they may not know which inspector might grandfather existing and which will require everything to code.