Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Jahooodie t1_j36yqly wrote

Reply to comment by halocene_epic in What should I eat right now? Late night foods, people by LuxuriousTime

My friend was just talking about this; Tony Baloneys' have fallen off HARD to the point where it's a no-go now

8

pixel_of_moral_decay t1_j378x3i wrote

It was never good, it was pure Instagram bullshit. So whatever it fell to just be god awful.

11

Jahooodie t1_j37aa5t wrote

I wouldn't hate on them that hard. I wanted to hate them so bad, but was genuinely surprised with the quality when they first opened in JC (expensive, but some unique things & great for something different as a treat). When that opening HQ crew left things dropped, and at that price point I don't risk lack of consistency. Anyone I know who has gone recently has declared them straight bad

1

pixel_of_moral_decay t1_j37b5jh wrote

I tried the Hoboken one at least twice over the years, And the JC one twice within the first several months of opening. All occasions were mediocre at best. A bit undercooked more often than not. Not cheap either. That’s no cheap 2am drunk pie.

But I think most random pizza places in the area could outdo them.

1

Jahooodie t1_j37ekir wrote

The JC location dropped hare within like 1 month of opening. There are probably a few dudes with the skills to manage the unique pies, and/or the ability to care. And if you want a simple plain or pepperoni slice, there is no point in getting that from Toney Baloney's.

Making it clear to folks, in case it sounds like I'm an apologist: It is NOT a recommend

2