Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

vbl1776 OP t1_j6e5kdv wrote

Reply to comment by MonkeySherm in Pizza recs for my parents in Chatham/Summit/Madison? by vbl1776

Thanks for this! They’ve tried Armenio’s, The Shop, and Hickory Tree. Hickory Tree was their go-to through the mid-90’s but has apparently taken a dark turn.

Edit: Also Coppola’s

1

MonkeySherm t1_j6f0xgg wrote

Sure thing! I haven’t tried any of those places but my mom likes Bellariva in New Prov for a good football pizza too, so that’s prob worth giving a shot. There’s a very highly rated spot on the one bite app in Short Hills that seems like it should be promising as well, but I’ve never been there either. There are a ton of places in north jersey that are worth a drive too, so keep that in mind!

Report back with your findings, I’m always down for a new slice.

1

Remarkable_Diver_128 t1_j6f5ue0 wrote

You trust Dave portnoy's opinion question mark

1

MonkeySherm t1_j6f7lou wrote

With regard to his reviews, I don’t take his word as gospel but it’s a relatively consistent barometer in my opinion, especially when you’ve got a couple of the same spots under your belt. I use it for the community ratings as well.

1

Remarkable_Diver_128 t1_j6fgw0d wrote

Well he's from Boston I lived in Boston to have the worst Pizza on the east coast

3

MonkeySherm t1_j6g1ul9 wrote

You make a fair point, but the guy’s also eaten more pizza than anyone else I can think of

3