Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

tristan957 t1_j5xmgro wrote

Why is the FAA not being investigated for their role in this? They signed off on whatever fraud Boeing may or may not have committed.

10

5AlarmFirefly t1_j5zn5ic wrote

The original MCAS system was supposed to be very rarely used with several backup sensors. After it was approved by FAA, Boeing changed the design, allowing the system to run at almost all times and making it rely on a sole sensor (which is absolutely bonkers engineering). They intentionally hid the changes from the FAA certifiers so they wouldn't have to retrain pilots. In fact, they specifically requested that the MCAS system be removed from training manuals, so 737 pilots didn't even know about it till it started making headlines.

There was a branch of the FAA that did know about the changes, but they didn't require Boeing to rerun their safety tests on the new system. However, they also weren't the certifying branch.

10

tristan957 t1_j5znmi2 wrote

Appreciate the explanation. So this was more of a procedural issue in that one branch can't tell the other branch to recertify the plane?

2

5AlarmFirefly t1_j5zoby3 wrote

Well, the one branch absolutely should have required the new safety tests, and maybe they assumed Boeing had informed the other branch of the changes? But never trust giant corporations to self-regulate I think is the takeaway message. Boeing is overwhelmingly responsible for the crashes. They even continued to hide the issues with MCAS after the first crash.

2

gazagda t1_j5zchh0 wrote

Not exactly, they just let the "fox run the hen house" type scenario

3