Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

ux3l t1_jb74h8c wrote

I know Grand Canyon is in the USA, but I don't associate both directly, so I wouldn't feel betrayed if something with a logo that looks like the Grand Canyon be made somewhere else than the US. I remember from my childhod chocolate filled cookies that looked like Koalas, and I doubt they were made in Australia.

1

BRIKHOUS t1_jb74z41 wrote

>so I wouldn't feel betrayed if something with a logo that looks like the Grand Canyon be made somewhere else than the US.

Fair, but not really the point. It's whether you'd think it's made in the US. If someone would think that, then it's misleading, and problematic.

>I remember from my childhod chocolate filled cookies that looked like Koalas, and I doubt they were made in Australia.

Ha, and that's because, to my knowledge, animals actually work the way you're suggesting for landmarks

1

ux3l t1_jb76204 wrote

> It's whether you'd think it's made in the US.

That was a No.

And Koalas makes me more think of Australia than the Grand Canyon of USA or the Matterhorn of Switzerland, rather the Alps in general.

2

BRIKHOUS t1_jb76os2 wrote

Are you from the US? A US person would likely think it was made in the US. Or a brit might think their beans are local if they gave a picture of the thames on the label.

Even if you personally wouldn't feel confused, can you see how a reasonable person might? That's the idea

0