Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

plugubius t1_irjjwkq wrote

My assumption is that was the argument, because federal courts are certainly the right place to hear state-law disputes between citizens of different states.

2

r33k3r t1_irjkdme wrote

I dunno. I think leases of real property are almost always governed by the laws of the state where the property is located, not whatever other state the parties happen to reside in.

2

plugubius t1_irjksit wrote

That is a question of choice of law, not federal jurisdiction. Illinois law will usually apply to Illinois properties, but that doesn't mean a New York federal court can't apply Illinois law.

2