GetPsily t1_jbk5xmt wrote
Reply to comment by Clarkeprops in There is nothing to say about truth, admits Simon Blackburn. Here he presents the deflationist approach to truth – one that aims to put an end to the search for a theory of truth, which Blackburn now recognises is futile by IAI_Admin
It's true in the context of our idea about what we call the physical world, but really there's no way for you to find out the truth or reality of anything. Only through the help of knowledge passed down generation to generation do you experience anything.
So technically that statement is true, but actually it depends on what you mean by "sun", "ice cube", "close enough", and "melt".
One could argue the sun itself doesn't do anything to the ice cube. Do you define the sun as an entity that has heat separate from itself and applies it to the ice cube? Or is the sun itself heat? Etc....
What do you mean by ice cube? An ice cube 1000x the size of the sun will probably not melt.
What do you mean by close enough? An ice cube left out in the sun can melt on earth, but also the earth has huge ice caps that haven't melted. Etc
I think you get the point. For all intents and purposes that we would use, yes it is true. But it ain't necessarily so, or not objectively true without specific context. I think it was George Box that said "all models are wrong, but some are useful."
But at the same time the statement is false because an ice cube will likely sublimate in the vacuum of space before it came close enough to melt.
Clarkeprops t1_jbktybf wrote
This just seems like semantics. I’m not following you. Sorry.
GetPsily t1_jbm595x wrote
No that's actually what I'm saying. It's ALL semantics. Actual truth/reality is not words, only theories and concepts.
" A tree has leaves" is false because "tree" is a word, nothing like an actual, tangible tree. How can a word have leaves? The statement is true in the linguistic, semantic sense only.
Basically all truths experienced by us have to be translated into words before they can be spoken to ourselves or others. So anytime we communicate, the recipient gets the words, not the true, actual things.
EDIT: TL;DR: There is objective truth, but you can't tell anyone, including yourself.
Clarkeprops t1_jbrda91 wrote
Every time I talk philosophy with someone versed in it, I leave more confused than before.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments