And on the point of program data duality. I’d be willing to delve into this idea more but it doesn’t actually seem necessary at this time for you to prove this or for me to refute it either way.

So in summation I’d say politely that these are good and interesting points but I believe you’ve smuggled free will into negation.

A DUMB AI could arguably fit these three definitions depending on how you worded them but I think the fact that a “dumb” aI could probably work with an infinite computational medium shows us that this specific point isn’t where the argument comes from because I personally really enjoyed this point.

Plz feel free to push back if you’d like to go over it with me