Submitted by ADefiniteDescription t3_10k8y95 in philosophy
Enlightened_Ape t1_j5ph76w wrote
Why don't we just make some specific laws concerning "non-human persons"?
AhmedF t1_j5q1j5c wrote
Because you have to define it all from scratch (legally). Personhood has a lot of laws built around it as is.
Krasmaniandevil t1_j5qbi39 wrote
The article notes several countries that have declared certain animals to be non-human persons, and the notion of corporate person is widely recognized.
If "we" refers to the USA, there isn't the political will to extend these rights to animals such as elephants or primates for many reasons (eg., Voter apathy, special interest groups that use animal testing, zoos, etc.).
Even if one sovereign decided to grant some animals personhood, that wouldn't necessarily be recognized outside that jurisdiction (e.g., two nations, state vs. federal govt.), so they would likely only be a "person" in specific contexts.
stumblewiggins t1_j5q58yn wrote
New laws require legislative acts, which are hard enough to get for uncontroversial things that a majority of people want.
The activists took the legal approach because there was potential to get the goal they wanted without legislation. A judge could have theoretically ruled that Happy constitutes a legal person, and was thus entitled to the protections afforded to legal persons. They didn't, but they could have.
I suspect that if not the activists involved in this example, some activists are working on getting legislation passed, but this probably seemed like a tactic worth trying as well.
Plutonic-Planet-42 t1_j5qqfnb wrote
Clearly corporations are people and deserve the same respect as humans.
ShalmaneserIII t1_j5r086c wrote
Arguably, you're not wrong, if by "respect" you mean how someone is treated.
If you expect to engage in transactional relationships with people to further your own ends, will obey explicitly agreed-upon rules but have no implicit ones, and have no particular concerns for the persons' wellbeing beyond those, you will treat humans and corporations the same.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments