Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Hands0L0 t1_j9qy2ad wrote

Reply to comment by Nano-Brain in Is ASI An Inevitability Or A Potential Impossibility? by AnakinRagnarsson66

I mean, not every human has the creativity to create new things. But that doesn't mean they aren't intelligent

1

Nano-Brain t1_j9r1gx0 wrote

I dont think that's true. I think even the dumbest humans have dreams that generate new ideas, however abysmal they may be.

But even if you're correct, unless the AI can extrapolate the data we give it into brand new hallucinations that dream up things we've never thought of, then it will never be different or smarter than us. This is because it will always be beholden to the data that we manually feed it.

1

Hands0L0 t1_j9r49i6 wrote

I think you may be overstating human creativity. There are plenty of visionaries among us who create new concepts, but the vast many of us are -boring-. We share the same memes and when we try to make our own memes they fall flat. How many people do you know have tried to write a book, and it ends up being rife with established tropes? How many hit songs use the same four chord progression? When was the last time you experienced something -truly- unique? It's been a long time for me, that's for sure.

So I don't think "making something totally unique" is the best metric for AGI. Being able to infer things? That's where I'm at. But I'm not an expert, so don't take what I'm claiming as gospel

1