Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

elverloho t1_je1ohfv wrote

Hi, Astronomer! I've been looking for someone to ask this question for a long time. Could FRBs be coming from different kinds of events (instead of all having the same kind of cause) and are there differences between FRBs (a sort of an FRB "fingerprint" if you will) by which to classify them into different categories?

Like, could some FRBs be the result of neutron star collisions while other FRBs are the result of alien hyperdrives and could we possibly tell the difference based on what we can observe?

8

evydude456 t1_je1ul5m wrote

(Different) radio astronomer here! There are two main types of FRBs: repeaters and non-repeaters. While we are far from understanding the source of every single FRB, it’s looking more and more likely that there is not one single explanation behind every single one. It’s possible that non-repeating bursts come from cataclysmic events like mergers between neutron stars or other heavy objects, while the sources of repeating FRBs could be compact objects like pulsars and magnetars, which have been observed to emit bright single pulses in radio waves.

In fact, CHIME, the radio observatory mentioned in this article, recently published the first large-scale catalog of FRBs. From the growing sample we’ve seen, it looks like there are other differences in the bulk populations of repeating and non-repeating FRBs— things like their pulse shapes as well as their brightnesses at different frequencies. This could also point to there being multiple sources of FRBs, but again, we’re not quite confident enough to draw any strict conclusions.

I will say that there’s no evidence that any FRB we’ve discovered so far has come from any extraterrestrial intelligence or non-natural sources. That’s why we’ve got to keep looking!

22

Andromeda321 t1_je2wktu wrote

Couldn’t have said it better. Thanks for stepping in! :)

11