Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

[deleted] t1_j1mce5n wrote

I like the one that will actually get built. Design isn't going to be nearly as important as sustainable funding, and that is going to take a new kind of business model. Any station will be a platform for science and a hot spot destination for rich people who can afford a trip. The money from rich people isn't going to cut it, just like first class airline tickets cannot fund an entire flight. So it'll be research projects that fund it. NASA will probably offer some cash for ongoing research, DoD as well. But will that be enough to justify the effort? Is that actually profitable? They'll need to go farther. They will need to sell research time to universities and private companies. And they'll need to have an entire human spaceflight support system. And they'll have to build and maintain this thing. And, and, and, and.

The economics of this idea are really tough, and flashy PR visions of potential designs exist for one reason - fundraising. They want to get people excited about what could be, get early investors to chuck in some money to start funding an enormously expensive project with very questionable return, just in terms of raw profit. The scientific return would be amazing, but science doesn't pay people's salaries.

So, I'll start getting excited when someone has a viable business model and stuff starts getting built. Until then, these are just fantasies.

Exhibit A: Bigelow was screaming from the rooftops that his space station would be operational in short order...20 years ago.

3

Mindless_Use7567 OP t1_j1mnpcl wrote

Well Axiom is contacted for adding 2 modules to the ISS so their Habitation modules are more or less financed by NASA so it mainly depends on if the research and power tower modules are built and docked.

NASA is providing partial development funding and paying for 2 astronauts constantly on orbit plus 200 experiments per year for the 3 that are part of the CLD program which is Orbital Reef, Starlab and NG’s station.

Orbital Reef and Axiom have already got some countries and private companies signed up to use their stations once they are up and running.

3

holmgangCore t1_j1pgou9 wrote

It’s almost like our economic system, built on the expectation of “return” and “profit”, isn’t really a good model for doing adventurous, high-risk projects.

1