DaRizat t1_j7ychmu wrote on February 10, 2023 at 7:22 AM

Reply to comment by jgiffin in [Meirov] The Pro Football Hall of Fame class of 2023: Darrelle Revis, Joe Thomas, DeMarcus Ware, Zach Thomas, Ronde Barber, Don Coryell, Joe Klecko, Ken Riley, Chuck Howley by BCLetsRide69

Not at all, if we were talking about more than 19 TDs maybe I'd reconsider. If you're going to put one PR in, you could make a case for Brian Mitchell over him since he did it more consistently over a longer period and was a better positional player. He's 2nd all time in AP yardage and Hester is 49th. And he's only trailing Hester by 4 TDs

jgiffin t1_j7ycxdv wrote on February 10, 2023 at 7:27 AM

>I think HOF worthy careers are people who can't be stopped simply by kicking the other way.

>Not at all, if we were talking about more than 19 TDs maybe I'd reconsider.

Well which is it lol

>And he's only trailing Hester by 4 TDs

That’s a lot when you’re talking about 14 vs 10. Almost 30% less. Imagine if the NBA scoring leader was 30% above second place…

DaRizat t1_j7ydhkp wrote on February 10, 2023 at 7:34 AM

I don't see any contradiction. Like I said we're talking about 19 total KR/PR Tds. You think 19 good plays is enough for a HOF career when there are every-down players with far greater contributions not making it in? That's nuts to me.

On your percentage point you're arguing my point that the total number of TDs is so insignificant that 4 would be a huge percentage.

It's fine to think Hester was awesome, I do too. He's just not HOF worthy to me.