> I can't tell if it just hasn't aged as well

When I watched The Sopranos for the first time in 2018 this was my exact thought as well. I quit right after finishing season 2 as well.

I don't know, at the time when I watched it, I just thought everything I was seeing in The Sopranos I'd seen done much more interestingly in other modern crime-dramas. I won't deny that it's groundbreaking though, but at that point (2018) I think it might've lost a lot of its appeal/value.

I will say though, out of the 2 seasons I watch, I saw 2 episodes that were really outstanding. Masterpieces even. One was titled "College". I don't remember the title of the other one.