Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

ouyin2000 t1_j9dr0hd wrote

Is it really edible if it's toxic?

46

TheTinyTinkerer t1_j9dv8sp wrote

Yes. You can eat almost anything smaller than your oesophagus and/or softer than your teeth.

50

mashtato t1_j9ehsqd wrote

Even I'm edible, but that, dear children, is cannibalism, and is in fact frowned upon in most societies. Yeah.

31

pooping_turtles t1_j9dw00s wrote

If you are dehydrated enough, people will choke on things otherwise of edible size, so technically it would be more correct if you started your statement with the caveat "If adequately hydrated you can eat almost dot dot dot.

8

miemcc t1_j9f3uk2 wrote

Everything is edible, sometimes only once!

4

Hippopotamidaes t1_j9fkbdy wrote

No. Edibility pertains to “fitness or suitability to be eaten.”

Poisonous foods aren’t “edible” because we’re not fit/suited to eat them.

1

testhec10ck OP t1_j9gc89h wrote

If it’s not exposed to toxins, than it’s safe to eat, but scallops travel, so there’s no way to tell if they were in contaminated waters. Farm raised scallops don’t have the same issue, since we know what water they were in, and theoretically you could eat the whole scallop (less the shell)

1