Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

raptor3x t1_j44zm2g wrote

Reply to comment by stokeledge2 in High beaming by ResponsibleExcuse727

Housings designed for halogens with a refractor design can still be ok with LED bulbs, especially if they're retrofit with the new ultrathin type LED bulbs so they can produce a sharp cutoff. Reflector housings should never be used with LED, or HID, bulbs though. That combination is the absolute worst.

3

Reasonable_Bend_1472 t1_j4667ds wrote

The sharp cutoff is one of the worst aspects of the LEDs... Well so are brightness and blue-white blindingness... They are just all-round terrible!

But the sharp cut-off provides a flashing effect whenever a car hits a bump, and if there is enough chromatic aberration in the lense the cut-off includes red and blue bands, so they even flash like emergency vehicles.

4

Catatonic27 t1_j47ia5t wrote

Thank you for describing that thing I've noticed every time one of these guys is behind me and I keep thinking I'm getting pulled over.

2

nomadicbohunk t1_j470f6m wrote

HID's and the wrong lenses... I'll share. Like 10 years ago, my car was a 20 year old pile. It's was great. My headlights were basically unusable at night. I got brighter bulbs a few times, and finally got the brightest HIDs I could source. They were adjusted right. I had to buy a safety torx driver to adjust them slightly in grad school after someone hit my car. I never got flashed. I knew the housings were yellow, but new ones cost too much and the ones at the salvage yard were yellowed too, but not as bad as mine. Anyway, I was visiting my parents and went to my mechanic buddy's house. We were talking and he saw my headlights. WTF duder? Those are the most oxidized shitty things I've ever seen. Let me fix that for you. At work I get $300 a set to do these on a semi. So he polished them up and clear coated them. I drove home right at dark. I no joke could see a stop sign light up over a mile away in one particularly downhill spot. The roads in that area are gridded by one mile so it's easy to tell distance. The reflections off the road signs I drove past were blinding me. I went to napa the next morning and got normal bulbs. It's a really low population area, so I never met anyone, but I was worried I was going to. It was absurd like an airplane light or the brightest offroad lights I'd ever seen. We had just bought my dad a $600 or something absurd brightest spotlight made for checking cattle and these were brighter.

1

raptor3x t1_j478odb wrote

Yeah, HIDs in a reflector housing are a complete disaster. At least with the average LED bulb the beam pattern sort of matches what you would get from a halogen bulb (there are some that are really close now but they're super expensive). With HIDs the beam pattern is completely different and so the headlight often ends up throwing more light up, to the sides, and immediately in front of the car than down the road where you actually want it. What ends up happening is not only do you blind everybody but everything else is so bright, and so little light actually makes it down the road, that you're visibility can actually end up being noticeably worse since your night vision is impaired by how bright everything is immediately around you.

1

nomadicbohunk t1_j47grqj wrote

That's hilarious. Well, they do help if your car has almost opaque lenses. They've got that market cornered.

That does make sense with the lights blinding me on the highway signs. I vividly remember that one half hour drive.

1