Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

arethereany t1_j3dh9vj wrote

I'd choose DSOTM any and every day of the week. The Wall is too angsty and angry and doesn't have the wonder and exploration of Dark Side. Dark Side is a once in a generation masterpiece while The Wall is just an excellent album.

3

BattleAngelXX OP t1_j3dhjri wrote

Fair enough. I grew up with The Wall and NIN's Downward Spiral

3

me_not_at_work t1_j3dkksz wrote

DSOTM not just because it is (IMHO) a far superior album across the board, but because I don't really consider The Wall a Pink Floyd album. To me it is really the first Roger Waters solo album.

3

noobvin t1_j3dlku6 wrote

DSOTM for sure. Such a great album end to end and not a passion project of just Waters, like so many other albums are. Obviously the greatest "headphone album" of all time. Many agree since it stayed on the billboard charts for decades. It is quintessential Pink Floyd.

3

isthisnamestupid t1_j3drp9t wrote

The Wall will always have a soft spot in my heart. My first Floyd album, bought it a couple years after release, for the The Wall Pt.2, like the 12 year old I was. Fell in love with the band, and yeah DSOTM is the better album, but The Wall has too much nostalgia and memories attached.

3