Constant_Count_9497
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j7d14u9 wrote
Reply to comment by ThoDanII in Was it a good Idea for vercingetorix to take refuge with his army in Alesia in 52bc? by thereasonyousuffer
I think you underestimate the technology and structure of ancient cities
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j7cw5ge wrote
Reply to comment by ThoDanII in Was it a good Idea for vercingetorix to take refuge with his army in Alesia in 52bc? by thereasonyousuffer
While I agree is best to be skeptical about army numbers, given what historians project as the entire population of pre Roman Gaul (being around 5 million people) those numbers are fairly reasonable
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j69bb9h wrote
Reply to comment by DontWakeTheInsomniac in What's the earliest case of iron-smelting with hard evidence? by Ok-Goose-6320
I'm more confused with their idea about "blooming" because from what I can tell it's clearly an early smelting technique involving heating the ore to purify it while smashing it
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j61s6z2 wrote
What exactly is the Roman Era they're referring to? Are they saying that romans invented Iron smelting?
I'd direct your research if you're willing towards ancient India and China. From my cursory investigation they were smelting iron before the founding Rome.
Edit- It also seems the person arguing that "blooming isn't really smelting" is arguing semantics. Since blooming is in fact a method of smelting
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j4ht69v wrote
Reply to comment by EmperorG in I think that the term Byzantines is rightly used for adressing the Eastern Roman Empire. by VipsaniusAgrippa25
I think it shows that from even their own origin myth the romans adopt Greek history/myth.
There's plenty of things showing romans were Greek fanboys, the most apparent being tutored by Greeks (as apparently you're no a true civilized Roman aristocrat if you don't own/pay for an expensive Greek tutor)
I'll concede that they probably didn't REALLY consider themselves Greek, that was just a poor exaggeration on my part
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j4dnn0q wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in I think that the term Byzantines is rightly used for adressing the Eastern Roman Empire. by VipsaniusAgrippa25
It makes sense from the context that Byzantium was a small Roman city that Constantine turned into the cultural center of the eastern empire. At least from a chronological evaluation of the empire
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j4dh98c wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in I think that the term Byzantines is rightly used for adressing the Eastern Roman Empire. by VipsaniusAgrippa25
I've seen a few passionate people hating the term "Byzantine" but never offering a better name
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j4dh1n4 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in I think that the term Byzantines is rightly used for adressing the Eastern Roman Empire. by VipsaniusAgrippa25
True, they even claimed to be descendants of Anaeas. Romans were just grecophiles with a superiority complex
Constant_Count_9497 t1_iytraog wrote
Reply to comment by VacatedDosVile in What was history class like before the modern era? by SunsetShoreline
100% on the historical aspect, the fact that I can read the thoughts of a man that ran an empire, or of a man that was the tutor of many great men is astounding, and putting into perspective how people of the time thought. I'm screenshotting your comment so I remember to look into your recommendations
Constant_Count_9497 t1_iytqgt8 wrote
Reply to comment by VacatedDosVile in What was history class like before the modern era? by SunsetShoreline
Ever since picking up Aristotle and subsequently Marcus Aurelius' Meditations I've been a philosophy nut. I wish I found it earlier in life since it's definitely opened up my perspectives on quite literally everything
Constant_Count_9497 t1_iytjkml wrote
Reply to comment by koloquial in What was history class like before the modern era? by SunsetShoreline
Yeah, I learned everything stemmed from philosophy when I first cracked open a book of Aristotles teachings. I've respected philosophy a lot more because of that
Constant_Count_9497 t1_iyrvulx wrote
Well, since only the very wealthy were able to be educated, people like Alexander for example were tutored by famous historians/philosophers/mathematicians.
Everyone who wasn't the richest kid around would most likely have been tutored by students of these famous philosophers. (Pretty much anyone inclined in the scientific arts was a philosopher, as in the ancient eras all sciences were rooted in philosophy)
Constant_Count_9497 t1_ivbv246 wrote
Reply to comment by Neurocor in They fled persecution in Nazi Germany. Then the British put them behind barbed wire by lanzkron
The Allies were quick to snatch up as many Nazis as they could after the war.
Constant_Count_9497 t1_ivbutkp wrote
Reply to comment by arran-reddit in They fled persecution in Nazi Germany. Then the British put them behind barbed wire by lanzkron
That's your bad for assuming redditors have competent reading skills
Constant_Count_9497 t1_iv6hklk wrote
Reply to comment by tiredpiratess in The mysterious Viking runes found in a landlocked US state by bafangoolNJ
Yeah, I agree. That was a pretty uninformed take
Constant_Count_9497 t1_j8vdf2k wrote
Reply to comment by Welshhoppo in How different were the Italians and the Romans in the social war? by hhhhhab
I believe during this time Romans were will exempt from taxation, being more fuel on that fire