Unironically, I need something like this

Hole (referring to the holes as the next clue, and the holes got bigger as more bags were removed), eye (pronounced as in the letter I, and he has two of them as per the twin that you can't see [except in a mirror]), and throat (cut your throat amd it's probably the last thing you do)

Do you not know how nicknames work??

Alice can be short for Alison, it's a nickname