It's less about who's playing Geralt but more about why Henry left in the first case. In case you didn't hear yet, he quit as Geralt because the writers were sticking less and less to the novels and directors called him "annoying to work with" because he wanted the writers to do so and openly voiced his opinion about it
Frea_9 t1_iuexg7k wrote
Reply to comment by Both_Sheepherder5659 in Netflix, “New and Improved👍” by CaptFling
It's less about who's playing Geralt but more about why Henry left in the first case. In case you didn't hear yet, he quit as Geralt because the writers were sticking less and less to the novels and directors called him "annoying to work with" because he wanted the writers to do so and openly voiced his opinion about it