I am considering the Duckworth Comet Balaclava after seeing u/Junior_Ad2955's comment. Costs $40 after coupons at time of writing. I would consider Duckworth as well as Patagonia and Arc'teryx if I had to pick any one from the list.
Edit: Considering a wool scarf now!
Fuizaidomineer OP t1_ivmz8bw wrote
Reply to comment by jkrdr in [Request] BIFL Winter mask recommendations for daily student commute? by Fuizaidomineer
I was very much on board with getting a balaclava but you changed my mind! Are there any good brands that do scarves like these?