Ragidandy

Ragidandy t1_j5qu4v3 wrote

It depends on the un-stated specifics of OP's question. But generally, the more volume the fluid in the cylinder has (ie: the larger the cylinder), the smaller the percentage of the fluid that is in contact with the edges of the cylinder. So a smaller volume would have a greater proportion of its fluid dragging against the edges slowing the liquid.

3

Ragidandy t1_iuej4j2 wrote

But aren't you making the same assumption that the OP citation proved wrong? All the same arguments were made for diffraction, and now we see diffraction is possible. That doesn't mean reflection is possible, but it does negate or weaken this argument that it's impossible. Actually, if diffraction is possible, then a specific sequence of diffractors should be able to reflect, right?

9