RunNPRun0316

RunNPRun0316 t1_j6ckwpt wrote

Reply to comment by relliott22 in yes this is a real bill that has been introduced by Ministry_of__Truth

My mistake. You are absolutely correct. That does make this a pretty thorny ethical debate on par with “The Trolley Problem.”

Still, it’s not “coercive”nor is it necessarily “unethical.” Coercion requires a threat. Telling someone that they will not be giving a specific privilege if they do not provide a specific service is not a threat; it is withholding an incentive that would otherwise not be available.

As long as it is 100% the decision of the incarcerated individual whether or not to provide the service, I don’t see the ethical problems. Of course, the program would have to be administered by some outside party with ethical standards.

I would love to see an actual ethicist way in on this subject.

1

RunNPRun0316 t1_j68hemm wrote

Reply to comment by SophiaofPrussia in yes this is a real bill that has been introduced by Ministry_of__Truth

It is certainly persuasive but how is it coercive and unconscionable? If you accept these terms, you, you are granted a privilege. You earn that privilege upon a service that is is rendered upon your death: full stop.

You no longer have need of those organs. You will now give potential life and happiness to a complete stranger. You have moved from a very dark place to a place of altruism.

I will gladly donate my organs when I am gone. I’m sure that there are many people in prison who probably would have been easily persuaded to do so without receiving anything more than a sense of retribution. Now they could potentially see some benefit from their act of kindness.

If you want something to rail about, There are plenty of things to choose from in our “Justice system.” Private prisons, solitary confinement, bail, the war on drugs and prison labor all come readily to mind, but organ donation? Maybe I’m missing something but I don’t see it.

−1

RunNPRun0316 t1_iufm098 wrote

Reply to I moved here last month from Michigan; I do have a girlfriend but having a hard time making friends and adjusting. Any suggestions or places? by Boring_Mortgage7647

Look up November Project on Social Media. It’s a no judgment workout social club. People of all ages and all fitness levels work out together and do many things other than workouts as well.

They meet at 6:30 am on Wednesdays at Harvard Stadium and Friday at the park on the summit of Summit Ave in Brookline.

Look for Paul and say hi.

1