Shining_Silver_Star
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izr8sl9 wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
You have no evidence that this policy on native women was ever conceived, let alone implemented.
Also, why do you subscribe to the noble-savage myth? There is plenty of evidence against it.
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izr6xv9 wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
You think the Europeans tried to encourage the natives to attack other tribes for women?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izr0rio wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
They didn’t do so on account of their not having the ability, not out of moral superiority. They still fought over property, such as a women.
Why do you think they started treating women as property and killing each other only when Europeans came?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izqwn8w wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
You think the tribes didn’t fight each other before the Europeans arrived?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izqrsgu wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
Aboriginal intertribal warfare did occur, and it even involved transfers of property in the form of women.
See the section on traditional aboriginal warfare
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izq0eq1 wrote
Reply to comment by SpectralMagic in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
Conquest wasn’t just done for greed. It was also a means of security, at least in antiquity.
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izpx1ds wrote
Reply to comment by SpectralMagic in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
Why do you think conquest is evil?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izmxhw3 wrote
Reply to comment by verysillyhats in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
What steps do you think should be taken, in an ideal world?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izmwuq6 wrote
Reply to comment by OriginalCinna in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
It’s remarkable that such a thing even exists, a government willingly surrendering land as a matter of values. Almost all land on this planet has been conquered from others. I suppose the granting of a title still implicitly recognizes that the government of Australia possesses jurisdiction over the land.
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izmwn4x wrote
Reply to comment by verysillyhats in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
What do you mean by reconcile?
Shining_Silver_Star t1_izr9ap6 wrote
Reply to comment by bulletproofmanners in Native title granted to South Australian Wirangu people recognises it 'always will be Aboriginal land' by DaRedGuy
Because, hopefully, you care about truth. A claim with no evidence is baseless. Why do you subscribe to Indigenophilia?