aykavalsokec
aykavalsokec OP t1_ixbidzg wrote
Reply to comment by Laura-ly in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
There are other combinations to depict arms/hands.
They dont need to do streching exercises though.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix44oif wrote
Reply to comment by AgaOfKish in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
I am not thinking of anything, I just want to know if there is any other explanation.
I think divine revelation is not a good way of explaining similar cultural motifs.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix3vu8j wrote
Reply to comment by Uschnej in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Dawkins's meme is considered pseudoscience?
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix3vl7g wrote
Reply to comment by AgaOfKish in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Are you suggesting something like the collective unconscious of Jung or meme of Dawkins?
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2sy1m wrote
Reply to comment by ItsABiscuit in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Okay, this falls into the category of evolutionism.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2r8pg wrote
Reply to comment by ItsABiscuit in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Yes, imitation indicates they were in contact somehow, which falls into diffusionism.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2q8l8 wrote
Reply to comment by bertiewooster_swgoh in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
>way to push your pseudoscientific hogwash
Holy crap, what is with this prejudice?
I gave you ONE example. This can be multiplied.
"Or the physical constraints of the stylized nature of the artworks meant there was no other real place for the hands to go."
And what you describe here also falls into the category of evolutionism.
I just want to know if there are other accepted frameworks other than diffusionism and evolution.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2nt53 wrote
Reply to comment by bertiewooster_swgoh in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Artwork is intentional representation. When you look at a painting, sculpture, motif etc. every drawn line, etched detail has to have a purpose. Just like in architecture, if you look at a floor plan, even the smallest dot has a purpose.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2lfvn wrote
Reply to comment by ItsABiscuit in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
I will copy paste a comment which I wrote before;
One example I can think of are the statues found in Turkey, Indonesia and Easter Island. Their hands are depicted as being positioned around the navel/genitals.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2legz wrote
Reply to comment by 19seventyfour in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Yes, this falls into diffusionism.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2ld8w wrote
Reply to comment by Reddituser45005 in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Yes I did watch it and I am familiar with Hancock's work for far longer. I don't see the connection to the question.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2la48 wrote
Reply to comment by Hyphalspace in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Hmm yes. I was thinking about Dawkins's meme idea as well but didn't think about Jung. Thank you.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2l5v2 wrote
Reply to comment by bertiewooster_swgoh in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
I am asking this question because I recently read a book from Oscar Montelius and I am genuinely curious.
Don't worry I won't bring "pseudoarchaeology" into this, whatever that means.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ix2kx8r wrote
Reply to comment by chadberg in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
I don't think they explain intricate details. One comment I posted before is something like this;
One example I can think of are the statues found in Turkey, Indonesia and Easter Island. Their hands are depicted as being positioned around the navel/genitals.
aykavalsokec t1_ivkzk7s wrote
Reply to TIL that the "Lost City of Atlantis" was invented by the philosopher Plato, as a fake enemy for Athens that lost favour of the gods and was sunk in to the sea. by PDRugby
There are a lot of indications that the story was indeed true.
The "sinking" of Atlantis coinciding with the end of the Younger Dryas and the use of myths in Platos other dialogues are the main ones.
aykavalsokec OP t1_ixd6uvb wrote
Reply to comment by HolyCarp12 in How to explain similar symbols/motifs which are found around the world? by aykavalsokec
Well in that case, if two things are not exactly identical, we shouldn't mention resemblances/similarities, Or even inspirations.