noquarter53

noquarter53 t1_j2fjm56 wrote

What other solutions? Comprehensive economic and sociol transformation?

If there were an easy, efficient answer to this problem, it would have been implemented by now.

We should be ok with all-of-above strategies and be prepared to stop doing things that have low evidence of efficacy (including shrinking police budgets if it's proven that they aren't helpful).

8

noquarter53 t1_j2figqg wrote

Yeah, I'm just skeptical that having complicated bike lanes weaving in and out of traffic and highly walkable areas makes a lot of sense. DC is a massive tourist destination and out of town people don't understand how these lanes work. Piling layer upon layer of transportation has diminishing returns.

I would rather see some dedicated bike streets (close a couple E/W N/S streets for cars and repurpose them for only bikes).

−6

noquarter53 t1_j2f03ch wrote

Not sure if you can make the case that crime is trending down when murders increased 6 out of the last 10 years pre pandemic.

A professional, trustworthy police force is just as valuable, and there's research that shows more visible cops reduce crime.

>adding a new police officer to a city prevents between 0.06 and 0.1 homicides, which means that the average city would need to hire between 10 and 17 new police officers to save one life a year.

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2021/04/20/988769793/when-you-add-more-police-to-a-city-what-happens

Mental health and economic opportunities are important, but there's no shortage of jobs in the DC area. And, I would speculate that DC dovotes more resources towards mental health than a lot of cities.

15

noquarter53 t1_j2e97bh wrote

I live near Dupont and the bike lanes are super comprehensive, but honestly they seem underused... I rarely see people biking through the very walkable areas.

genuine question: When a neighborhood is extremely walkable, are bike lanes everywhere necessary?

−6