According to Range Planet, across their respective catalogs, Armstrong’s vocal range was G♯1 - B♭4, and White’s was F♯1 - E5. So White barely edges out Satchmo here.

Then again, the word “deep” is not well defined and open to personal interpretation. I would personally give it to White, as his voice is more resonant in lower registers, but you could make a case for either.

Of course, the real answer to your debate is Peter Steele.

This is not a critique of the music, per se, but nobody who loved the 80s would ever make a playlist like this. Some of these songs aren’t even from the 80s (Hold On, All for One, Release Me). Breakfast at Tiffany’s is closer to being a song of the 2000s than a song of the 80s. It released in 1995.

The original is best. The Jeff Buckley and K.D. Lang covers are pretty good. The Bono cover might be the worst cover song ever produced by a major label artist.

Good ‘ol Charlie Brown… yes, sir. How I hate him!