Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

5spd4wd t1_iw45j6u wrote

They could use a good wipe-down with CLR. And then oiling the screws.

25

BusLandBoat t1_iw4g9x4 wrote

Milwaukee makes some seriously good quality stuff.

9

vitimilocity t1_iw4ldmq wrote

I've had their pair of left and right cutters. Probably a defect but it was disappointing to see it snap on the blade with the 2nd cut.

9

shredsickpow t1_iw4prh0 wrote

No you did not. I worked at Milwaukee as a product designer from 2007-2009 and the hand tools were just starting in the early development / ideation sketches . Those came on the market in maybe 2010-12 somewhere at the oldest.

482

BloodyLlama t1_iw4q5zu wrote

I've got 50+ year old snips of unknown origin that are just as good as a new pair. I think the design requirements of tin snips makes them quite durable if the hinge mechanism doesn't get too sloppy.

18

spooney t1_iw4rozu wrote

If you cut a lot of tin those are trash. Real buy it for life snips would be Midwest or the old Prosnips(RIP) from before Irwin bought them out.

17

EnragedEmu t1_iw4uk8u wrote

I prefer Wiss. Cheap, easy to find, made in US. Owned buy Crescent, which is still an American company. But also, yeah. Milwaukee didn't do hand tools back in 05

24

kdogmizzle5191 t1_iw52q5x wrote

I had the same pair for like 5 years. I've cut through lots of joist hangers and all sorts of crap before they died on me.

2

madmax_br5 OP t1_iw53fny wrote

Maybe I'm mistaken, but I definitely bought these long before I moved cross-country in 2011, Since I used them extensively on a loft buildout in 2010. Of that I can be sure. So it's possible I bought them in 2010 and got them confused with a previous pair I purchased earlier.

33

ThatDarnScat t1_iw55kwb wrote

Just want to give you props. Milwaukee makes some legit good stuff that (a lot of) is made in the US. I took a lean manufacturing workshop with a couple of guys from the Greenwood facility (Sawzall blades) and got to hear about the fab and heat treat process.

Good stuff

11

bigpenguin55 t1_iw5a5zz wrote

I have a pair of lefts and rights of these that I use every day, I will never give them up cause the new handle design of the Milwaukee’s isn’t as good imo

1

crclOv9 t1_iw5ft5y wrote

I’ve got three years into my $20 Milwaukee red snips; gotta replace them in about another year I’d say; they are my favorite on the budget side of things.

8

handen t1_iw5la5i wrote

Yeah, Milwaukee hadn’t even birthed its prodigal son Alice Cooper yet, and OP claims to have owned these shears in advance of Billion Dollar Babies? Un-freaking-believable.

6

sayracer t1_iw5mk80 wrote

$234 for Stahlwille??????I'm not stranger to paying a premium for tools but this is absurd. I'm a Tinknocker. There's nothing you can do to stop stainless from bearing up snip blades

5

HisokasBitchGon t1_iw5nxf2 wrote

milwuakee used to have good hand tools... now they only focus on power tools that last 1 year since purchase

1

UnintentionalIdiot t1_iw5o7fv wrote

These are bulldog snips. Better for cutting thicker material. In the hvac industry you’d use these to cut through seams of ductwork where there’s multiple layers, or heavy gauge slip and drive which are used to connect and hang ductwork. They’re good for their purpose, but not great for making long cuts because they’re short. So good short cutters get good leverage for strong short cuts

17

F-21 t1_iw638st wrote

Those are very likely not made by those brands. Hazet, Stahlwille and Gedore sell top end tools, but they mainly focus on manufacturing those basic forged handtools like the sockets and wrenches, a lot of other stuff is rebranded from other more niche brands.

I think Knipex does not make them either.

The most well known top end snips from Germany are made by Bessey and it is very likely they supply them to those top brands (Hazet, Gedore and Stahlwille). NWS also makes them.

Buying Bessey snips is cheaper than buying Hazet, even if they're the same just different branding...

3

F-21 t1_iw651yv wrote

They're 60-70€ here in Europe.

I don't know if Stahlwille, Hazet or Gedore really make them anyway. Bessey is the German manufacturer known for such snips, and NWS also makes them. It's likely the other brands get some of those and have them rebranded (but I'm not 100%...). For many tools, the niche manufacturers are the best. Hazet, Gedore and Stahlwille do manufacture their own stuff, especially sockets and wrenches, but they rebrand lots of stuff like Screwdrivers (I think both Hazet and Gedore supply them from Oplast, while Stahlwille might get them from Witte).

5

tangerinedream555 t1_iw678d1 wrote

I can tell you tool bought from Ace hardware with the Ace Hardware brand on it will go too dull to do anything useful within 3-4 uses.

1

diegobomber t1_iw682w2 wrote

Milwaukee hand tools aren’t known for their quality, interesting those held up so long.

3

antihero12 t1_iw6c01h wrote

The color coding makes it look like half Milwaukee, half DeWalt

2

G05TheBox t1_iw6tn0o wrote

Malco and Knipex, only high end tools I can actually touch in a store lol. Hilti also at Home Depot lol.

I hear back in they days (from How it's made, best show ever en passant!) that Mastercraft Maximum wrench key were produce in the same shop as Mac Tools! 🤫🤥

1

drive2fast t1_iw77i66 wrote

Milfuckee makes great cordless tools (my industrial contracting shop is mostly red) but most of their hand tools and especially their cutting tools like blades / bits are fucking garbage.

Project Farm on youtube proves this again and again. He does exceptionally well thought out tests and their tools perform poorly most every time.

3

madmax_br5 OP t1_iw79xkp wrote

Evidently this pair was one of the first to roll off the line; it’s possible they’ve cheapened them over time to save cost. I’m also surprised how long they lasted!

−3

kb31ne t1_iw7a81r wrote

Aren’t they Chinese also?

2

5spd4wd t1_iw7x43c wrote

CLR can remove rust from metal (and other subtrates), but if the metal has corrosion that's eating into the mteal it can't repair that.

My city has tap water that leaves a crusty residue over a time, a fairly short time. I use CLR-soaked paper towels and lay them firmly on the surface of my porcelain & stainless sinks as well as around the fixture.

I also use CLR and a pumice stone to remove the toilet bowl hard water deposit ring.

2

Arcansis t1_iw821hh wrote

Aviation straight shears, the most useless type of shears to exist. Those end up in the garbage. Offset shears are where it’s at. If you do any real tin work, yellow handled shears do not belong in your tool box.

1

drive2fast t1_iw8vwhc wrote

Same parent company.

But I did say that I buy the red cordless tools for my contracting company. They are mostly amazing, save for the 3-4 year old trash grade brushless onekey drills (top end models, bad chucks, weak bodies) and the new 1/2” impact wrenches that keep exploding. I’m so glad I bought the last gen impact.

Did you see the inside of the 1/2” impact failures yet? They removed 1/2 of the support on the planetary gearset so it just shears all the pins. It looks like they let a first year engineer go crazy with cost cutting inside there. Even the best companies make stupid decisions now and then.

1

__Snafu__ t1_iy1yuhu wrote

meh. Klein tin snips are where it's at...

try the kleins...

2