We really like Eataliano https://www.eatalianomarket.com/

Tino's is also good but a little pricey.

I've liked trattoria e pizzeria da Enrico and Coalfire as a NY style fan. Not as impressed with Tino's.

I like Philly's Best in Elkridgre

I'm surprised you don't like Trattoria! My girlfriend grew up around Italian-owned pizza shops and said it's the closest she's had to that quality. It's the best I've had around here too, with HomeSlyce second.

Anthony's in Clarksville.

The best NY style pizza in Columbia is the Waterloo pizza at the Exxon on LPP.

Lots of other good stuff too

I used to like Trattoria years ago, but then they changed their recipe somehow and it wasn't as good

Homeslice is a chain.

So true! Just had it today.

Sure, but an extremely small one (only 7 locations, and all in MD/DC)

As a regular type pizza place nothing too fancy and some good specials, I haven't had a problem with Pizzaman in Oakland Mills area.

Coal Fire is good. Had a great rep too. Still good but, in our opinion, not as good as it was ~10 years ago. Brick oven cooked so there’s that.

Try Grottos!

This. Coal Fire is darn close to what you get in Italy.

If you're willing to go to Catonsville, go to Scittinos.

Came here to say this. I live in Catonsville and I will drive all the way to this gas station to get pizza.

I'm not sure about elkridge but the thunder hill location is awesome. One topping XL special with pickup is like $10 and is way too much food.

Coal Fire is decent.

What happened with Home Slyce? Oddly enough, I got a taste for their pizza.

Big fan of homemade pizza. Just buy a flat bread, sauce, Italian seasoning, toppings mozzarella and put it on a pizza stone

Legit good so easy and cheap

Three brothers was the best back in the day, not sure why they’re no more

Gianni’s in Elkridge. Farther drive, but much better in my opinion.

We like Homeslyce, but its kinda pricey

‘Sort of’ close by is Mama Romas in odenton. Best pizza I ever had in the area.

Best Neapolitan pizza - Facci Best loaded pizza - Blaze laurel

Coalfire and Neo Pizza were meh

This is the right answer.

Murazzi food truck, very simple but very good

Sorrento's in Arbutus is one of my local favorites, a bit of a drive but worth it. Pazani in Elkridge (Marshalee Drive, just off Rt 100 & 103)

Home Slyce by design is good, decent quality ingredients and good selection. But they aren’t consistent, sometimes it’s good other times just a greasy mess.

I got them on a good day, then. :)

for carry out, i like Pizza Bolis in wilde lake. mostly b/c i can walk there and if you order online for carry out, they have a large for like $12

not the best pizza, but for the price its a great contender

“Buy a flatbread” is definitely not the answer. That’s flatbread, not pizza dough. Shit, even the Pillsbury “pizza crust” soda-dough is better than an already baked flatbread. Miles better. But if you’re cooking it at home why not just grab a ball of pizza dough. It’s sold at like every grocery store around here. Regardless, your answer is wrong as OP is asking for restaurant options. Clearly they aren’t looking to cook one at home.

Haha what garbage taste in pizza you have. Downvoters agree, grottos is the worst pizza columbia has to offer, hands down. Grosso Pizza.

Gesus Krist … I hate you and I don’t even know you

Fucking A man .. so much passive aggressive “I know better than you” bullshit for a conversation about pizza

Lighten up

I’m allowed to like my own pizzas .. you go like your own pizzas

Yeesh are you okay? Is this how you handle all criticism? Take it easy, ya kook. You didn’t answer the question that was asked, just accept it and move on.