Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

DrWangerBanger t1_jdrr68n wrote

I can't speak to Sally's but I had the Fairfield pepes a few times over the years before the pandemic and I found it pretty hit or miss. It seemed like it depended on who was working that day, or something. But I will say it was more often a hit than a miss.

9

tfl03 t1_jdrya16 wrote

They’re fine. But don’t expect it to be anything like the original.

2

CharacterPayment8705 OP t1_jdrye43 wrote

I’ve never been to the original (not in the mood to drive into New Haven)

1

tfl03 t1_jdrza3s wrote

It’s a very park-able city. Definitely worth a trip. Underrated city imo

4

curbthemeplays t1_je3v2m2 wrote

It’s not a hard drive. Or go to Zuppardi’s or Mike’s in West Haven, Papa’s or Jimmy’s in Milford.

1

Novel_Mix2963 t1_jds01jk wrote

I cry tears of joy into my Pepes pie before consuming it.

2

Tightlines68 t1_jds11wq wrote

Waterbury is good when they don’t mess up your order . We order online and get there at the correct time , girl says ok , hang on . I then watch the wonderful young men make my pizzas (3 ) while I’m standing there . She’s says it’s going to be 10 minutes . Yeah ok . 28 minutes later its ready . A lot Of of shit going on in that kitchen. I watched a girl braid another’s hair over the boxes and another one eating a slice while working near customers pies. Teary tasted good but the bull shit was unreal

2

QuestorPS7 t1_jdrvs3r wrote

Never been to Fairfield, but West Hartford and Waterbury were always fine.

1

charcuterie_bored t1_jdwit5k wrote

I’ve heard bad reviews about the Sally’s in Fairfield. I like Fairfield Pepe’s.

1

Crixxxxxx1 t1_jdxvvl4 wrote

Beverly’s in nearly Black Rock beats them both.

1

curbthemeplays t1_je3v453 wrote

Fairfield Pepe’s is very inconsistent lately. Often too thick and doughy.

1

th3matad0r t1_jdub37o wrote

IMO neither of these pizza places are worth the price let alone the wait and hassle. Bar and modern are much better In new haven. Fairfield is bleak with choices to eat, only place I can think of near by is hub and spoke that is good

0