Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Jaded_Prompt_15 t1_j8hwhgz wrote

Article:

>Hypothetical advanced life that we have zero evidence exists might hypothetically do this

Headline:

>Aliens might do this!

It's just a clickbait headline

138

kittykatkin t1_j8i78bl wrote

Aliens use this one simple trick.

55

WildGrem7 t1_j8kl059 wrote

Alien casinos hate it when you do this but they can’t stop you!

0

leaky_wand t1_j8korpm wrote

But the science itself sounds interesting. It seems counterintuitive that a black hole could store information or be useful for computation. Can anyone eli5?

2

Iffykindofguy t1_j8hz99z wrote

I thank the universe I grew out of my "jaded" phase

−5

Gari_305 OP t1_j8hxrc8 wrote

I doubt it's click bait if there's an actual study that says the same thing.

I understand your hesitation, however, why do a click bait with an attached study?

−31

Jaded_Prompt_15 t1_j8hy1jd wrote

The study says black holes could hypothetically be used like this.

The headline implies aliens exist and might be doing this.

Which is why the headline is clickbait.

>why do a click bait with an attached study?

So people click it...

20

OakenGreen t1_j8jfnfe wrote

I don’t think anyone’s gonna read the headline and think “oh my, not only did they discover aliens but the first they’re telling us is how their computers work before announcing the discovery of said aliens… Neato!”

1

wwiinndyy t1_j8k9le7 wrote

This is dumb. Everyone knows that we aren't sure if alien life exists, and no part of the title is claiming to have discovered them. You guys should really look at context

0

Gari_305 OP t1_j8hyi2c wrote

Actual headline in thestudy attached

>Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civilizations

Actual headline

> Aliens May Be Using Black Holes as Quantum Computers

They're both one in the same, not so much click baity there

−22

Jaded_Prompt_15 t1_j8i1bwu wrote

If you think either of those means aliens exist...

2

TrekForce t1_j8icqsb wrote

I don’t think either of them imply aliens definitely exist. I think both are basically saying “If aliens exist, they could use black holes as quantum computers”.

One sounds sciency and the other sounds more standard English.

5

mi2h_N0t-r34l_ t1_j8ia4rg wrote

That would never make a difference to me.

Seems reminiscent of the "threads of fate" from "Wanted" (the movie where they curve bullets).

I am hesitant, however, to call the notion outright ridiculous...

My personal take on the theoretical utility of black holes? Blast 'em - find a means of destroying or destabilizing them - there's probably gold in them there black holes...

1