It's a subjective question ultimately, so you could be right with either. If you polled the world, my money would be on Hendrix as he's usually widely regarded as the best. The dude was a freak on guitar. He could play it four different ways (normal & reversed right handed & normal & reversed left handed), & was just great with the different tones & sounds he could elicit from his instrument. Page was great though as well, nothing being taken away from him.

I won't "tare" you apart for asking that, but I will for using "tare" instead of "tear"...