Comments
couchasianktina t1_is4laxz wrote
Can someone better explain the position of the medical ethicists? In a world where nobody would take them seriously, I can see how information like that could be confusing and difficult to deal with.... But hasn't this woman demonstrated enough accuracy that some doctor(s) would believe her and be able to counsel these potential patients by her referral? Especially since (if I'm reading the article correctly) early-stage treatment are mild lifestyle modifications and not invasive procedures?
random_shitter t1_is4rbjv wrote
My amateur 2 cents: in theory you're probably right, in practice... I'd imagine a calm, peaceful reaction is not guaranteed if somebody randomly comes walking up to someone to give them an out-of-the-blue lifechanging diagnosis which has a large rizsk of not be getting serious, either by the person or their doctor.
[deleted] t1_is55kc8 wrote
[deleted]
Mega_Trainer t1_is59hvc wrote
It's honestly wild that a human has a good enough smell to detect this. I remember reading the article about her situation and I think her accuracy was 100%. The only person in the group who didn't have Parkinsons that she smelled ended up developing it some time later. I wonder if we will create a device to detect the smell or if they've isolated the compound producing the smell that they can detect with blood tests
crazy_gambit t1_is5fg5m wrote
She's probably not the only one that has a sense of smell good enough to detect it, but she was also exposed to the smell for a very long time, so she learned to identify it. Amazing nonetheless.
frozen_beet11 t1_is5ifdq wrote
I’d guess she can smell a protein breakdown, enzyme presence, certain acid that exists when the brain is experiencing these symptoms. Just a guess, no real knowledge on my end.
alexius339 t1_is5j29z wrote
Imagine one day she just gets that smell with no one around.. and realises its her
Ok_Skill_1195 t1_is5jcud wrote
Like old people smell, but for the brain.
chodthewacko t1_is5jzre wrote
She's not smelling the brain degeneration. I believe She's smelling a enzyme/chemical combination uniquely created by Parkinsons that comes out when they sweat.
Could_be_persuaded t1_is5kf49 wrote
She could probably train dogs to help.
Falcfire t1_is5lf9i wrote
I imagine there's a mix of good and bad feelings there. Like "hey we found a tumor, sure sucks but good thing we found it now and can start treatment ASAP, might delay the worst long enough you won't even notice"
Nobias447 t1_is5m1s4 wrote
We simply cant rule out the idea that her smelling people is giving them Parkinsons. /s
Paolo2ss t1_is5m54s wrote
The doctors 100% believe her. Just in the same way that diabetes urine has a certain small, this woman proved that this sickness also has a certain smell.
random_shitter t1_is5nbdo wrote
Yeah, well, there may be a perceived difference between going to a doctor and walking down aisle 4.
PrettyKuhli t1_is5o7gz wrote
My mother could smell UTIs before family members knew they had them, and she can smell stomach problems on people’s breath. Idk how she does it, but she says those two smells are VERY strong. I wonder if it’s similar?
snarkypant t1_is5obgd wrote
Perhaps! We should apply for grants!
Just_wanna_talk t1_is5ptwz wrote
Also that she's accurate enough to pick out that particular smell. Sometimes I can't even confidently say if I'm smelling vanilla, coconut, or banana.
Brutalitor t1_is5tins wrote
They say in this article that they swab someone's neck with a cotton ball and they can examine that ball for enzymes that indicate Parkinson's.
[deleted] t1_is5uwrh wrote
[deleted]
stratjr123 t1_is68ia9 wrote
Why don't they just figure out what exactly she is smelling, like what chemical is something and then develop tech or drugs around that?
Mai-ah t1_is6ah1e wrote
I think thats the idea?
stratjr123 t1_is6c1mk wrote
I'm a redditor my dear, i don't read articles before i comment
booglemouse t1_is6gkc2 wrote
I know a (former) nurse who recognized her own brain aneurysm symptoms, saved her own life by being able to react quickly and get to help in time. Knowledge is power, I guess.
words_of_j t1_is6kuw5 wrote
I can smell it when folks are coming down with illness, or fighting off something. It’s not a pleasant smell - I just want to stop breathing until I’m clear of it. The smell shows up most when a cold or flu is going around in a group I’m part of (school or work). It’s pretty spot on, and the smell is there a day or three before symptoms start.
ParkieDude t1_is78wgm wrote
Diagnosis of Parkinson's Disease is typically after the person knows "something isn't right" but tries to find out what it is.
A few, upon diagnosis, go into deep despair and do not recover.
Most live in denial for a few years.
Others are "OK, what should I do now."
The last thing anyone wants is a random stranger walking up to them and telling them.
90sPositivity t1_is7w1pm wrote
I have chronic kidney stones and can 'taste' when my kidneys are failing. Kinda metallic on my breath.
FlippantMan t1_is8n40p wrote
Yeah this exactly is the wild part to me. Like I can smell all kinds of things. I just don't know what they are.
theshowmustgo1on t1_is8t8px wrote
I was thinking the same thing. I bet so many people can actually smell diseases n such but just have no idea what that smell represents. I'm sure if they knew they would help people with their gift, I know I would.
szai t1_isedkot wrote
My pee smelled weird when I was going through fulminant liver failure. I think in my case it was bilirubin. I wouldn't be surprised if I was sweating it out as well. My whole body was stained yellow. It definitely has a smell though.
AutoModerator t1_is4ez7s wrote
Reminder: this subreddit is meant to be a place free of excessive cynicism, negativity and bitterness. Toxic attitudes are not welcome here.
All Negative comments will be removed and will possibly result in a ban.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.